Who's that Girl?


The Recruiting Tool I Want- Baggage

Originally posted: April 22, 2010 on TrishMcFarlane.com

Every couple months, DISH network puts a few “free” channels on our service for us to try out for a couple weeks.  Channels come and they go.  Right now, the Game Show Network (GSN) is one of the free channels in preview.  Now, I really haven’t watched game shows since…..well, since I don’t know when.  Probably back when that cool British chick was asking REALLY hard questions on that show The Weakest Link.  Well, GSN has a great new show I’m loving and I think it would be great to have at work as a recruiting tool. It’s called ‘Baggage’.  You can check out a clip here.

The premise is that Every Person Has Baggage they bring into the relationship.  Jerry Springer is the host and he brings out contestants who get to choose a date based on the other contestants revealing their “baggage” that progressively gets worse.  Let’s pretend the main contestant is a man.  So, at first, all three ladies reveal a small suitcase with some minor baggage.  It might be something like “I snore at night”, “I am always late for dates”, etc.  Next, three medium sized bags are opened but the man does not know which lady the bag belongs to.  These bags take it up a notch to things like “I live with two men”  or “I shave my whole body”.

The man eliminates the baggage that is a “deal breaker” for him and then learns which lady the bag belongs to.  She’s out of the game.   Now, the remaining two ladies  have to reveal their large suitcase, the one with the most baggage.  These are the crazy ones like “I have 19 cats” or “I am still in love with my ex”.  The man has to decide which person’s baggage is a better match with his.  Now we’re down to the man and the lady that was selected.  The man now has to show her HIS baggage and she makes the ultimate decision on whether or not his baggage is not a deal breaker for her.  If not, there’s a date.  Otherwise, both lose and go home.

When we’re hiring, we know that every candidate that walks into the door has baggage.  We ALL have baggage.  The question is whether we can get any of that to come out during our interviews so that we can determine if that baggage is a match with our organization, right?  It might be fun to have this game show at work.  Let’s imagine you have three candidates that you’ve narrowed it down to for a certain position.  Now they all have to show you their baggage. In the suitcases you see:

  1. I can never seem to make it to work on time.
  2. In the past some co-workers have said I wear too much perfume.
  3. I sometimes play music too loud in my cubicle.

Ok, let’s think about this.  Candidate number one is bad, but maybe we could coach her to get her to show up on time.  Candidate number two wears too much perfume but you can help correct that.  And candidate three, not that is something that won’t affect us because we don’t allow radios here on our desks.  Now they sit down and three medium size suitcases open.  You don’t know which one belongs to each candidate.  They are:

  1. I’ve fallen asleep at a meeting.
  2. I steal pens and post it notes from work.
  3. I once hooked up with a co-worker at the company picnic.

Ok, let’s eliminate the candidate with bag  number two.  Stealing is just WRONG and if she’ll steal the small stuff without batting an eye, she’ll take bigger things.  That’s the deal breaker in this company!

Round Two

Now we have our two remaining candidates.  They each go take their place by the baggage that is theirs.  Now it’s time to open the big suitcases.  Here’s what we see:

  1. I say I’m a great public speaker but I really freeze up every time and freak out.
  2. I served 90 days in a Canadian jail

Ok, now this one is easy.  We’ll eliminate jail bird girl because we would have found that in the background check eventually. So we’re ready to make our offer to the girl who can’t make it to work on time, who has fallen asleep at a meeting, and who is not a great public speaker.  Wow, I’m scared.  None of their baggage was great.   She really wants the job and says yes.  Now we’re a match and go off happily into the sunset.

I know that all sounds crazy, but that is really what we’re doing.  We talk to people to try to figure out all we can then eliminate candidates if they have baggage that is a “deal breaker” for the organization.  Don’t we?  The truth is that as good as a candidate may be, you are still hiring someone with several negatives that on paper could look really bad even though they’re the one you want.

So, what are some deal breakers in your hiring process?  What are some of the things you’ve learned in the interviews that just made you say, “Next” ?  Share them in the comments.

Leave a Comment

How we can help

Led by Trish Steed and Steve Boese, H3 HR Advisors harnesses over 40 years of experience to delivery HCM insights and guidance to global organizations.

Advisory services

By leveraging technology, analytics, and our deep industry knowledge we can help you to reposition your workforce and ensure that you have the right people with the right capabilities in the right roles to positively impact the growth of your business. 

HR Happy Hour Podcast Network

Created in 2009, The HR Happy Hour Show is hosted by Steve Boese and Trish Steed and is the longest continuously running internet radio show and podcast on Human Resources, HR Technology, Talent Practices, Workplace and Leadership topics. 

Speaking Services

We work closely with every client to customize your content - keynotes, webinars, research, infographics, and buyer’s guides - to inspire, educate and inform the audience enabling you to reset and realign your organization for a talent-led breakthrough.

Get in touch

Talk to us today and find out how we can help you and your organization leverage HCM technology to attract, onboard, retain and manage top talent.